Sully's GastroPub Idaho Falls
Sully's GastroPub Logo

Sully's GastroPub

@

4.6729 reviews

Sully's GastroPub offers a delightful mix of classic American dishes with a local twist. Known for its laid-back vibe, it invites diners to enjoy juicy burgers, hearty sandwiches, and flavorful cocktails. The inviting atmosphere makes it a perfect spot for casual meals and gatherings. Located at 504 Shoup Ave, Idaho Falls, this pub prides itself on quick service and a welcoming environment. From the moment you step in, you'll feel the warmth of the community around you.

The menu boasts an impressive variety of food and drinks, ensuring there's something for everyone. With a price range between $10 and $20, diners can indulge in satisfying fare without breaking the bank. The accessible setting makes it easy for groups and families to gather, while the well-curated drink menu enhances your dining experience. Whether stopping by for lunch or dinner, Sully's has a charm that keeps people coming back.

About

Sully's GastroPub stands as a beloved fixture in Idaho Falls, known for its vibrant atmosphere and hearty menu. The pub has quickly become a go-to destination for locals craving comfort food. The owner, inspired by a passion for hospitality, envisioned a place where every guest feels at home. Community ties run deep here, as many patrons are regulars who appreciate the familiar faces and friendly service.

Nestled in a bustling part of town, Sully's benefits from its accessible location. A mix of tourists and locals fills the pub, creating a lively environment. The inviting decor reflects a modern yet rustic aesthetic, giving it character while maintaining comfort. From the colorful murals to the cozy seating arrangements, the ambiance enhances the dining experience. This pub is not just about food; it's about connecting with friends, family, and fellow community members.

Get in Touch

504 Shoup Ave, Idaho Falls, ID 83402, United States

Opening Hours

  • Monday Closed
  • Tuesday 11:00-21:00
  • Wednesday 11:00-21:00
  • Thursday 11:00-21:00
  • Friday 11:00-21:00
  • Saturday 11:00-21:00
  • Sunday Closed

Where to Visit

Get Directions

Customer Reviews

"Went here for a good burger, got a really good burger! The presentation of the food was good, fries were a little salty for my taste. The flavor of my burger was good. Good pub atmosphere. Definitely will be back, lots of fun options for burgers too."

- ParksPlace S.

"I tried the smack your grandma burger ( something like that). As far as novelties go, it was a good burger. I thought the berry jam was a bit too overwhelming, but it was fun and the pattie was really good. I tried the pastrami sand as well and would recommend that to anyone and everyone. The floor under our table was exceedingly sticky from a spilled beer that hadn't been properly cleaned, but then again it's a pub."

- Joshua M.

"Loved this place. Greeted by the hostess who made us feel like she was glad to see us, which is rare these days. All the sandwiches were just as advertised on the menu and everyone in our party was satisfied. Sandwich sizes are very generous. I'm definitely going back."

- Jim J.

"Got the katsu chicken sandwich. Sandwich was enormous and the chicken was cooked perfectly. Could have gone with a single piece of chicken instead of two on the sandwich, but it was excellent. Fries were seasoned well but were a bit limp. Could have been crispier. The Caesar salad was disappointing. The atmosphere of the restaurant is very cool and well done."

- James C.

"The trashcan is a great sandwich. They have some amazing loaf fries appetizers. I heard the burgers were amazing. I recommend Sully's Gastropub."

- Ben M.

"Amazing find in downtown Idaho Falls. The food was SO GOOD! I had a patty melt on marble rye with onion rings. My husband had the Sloppy Josh with fries. Both entrees were so tasty. Our bill was about $40. The ambiance is great: Good music, comfortable seating, and just-right lighting. Service was very attentive and friendly, and everyone was just absolutely beautiful! They really fit in with the pub look, in their style. It was fairly quiet, so the owner came to our table repeatedly to check on us. They even have pool tables to play for their guests to use free of charge. The menu was so full of great options, we'll definitely be back often to try more dishes. Just GO! You will not be sorry. **Update 9/17/25**STILL a 5/5!! We really enjoyed our food and had some much needed fun as a couple playing pool. We ordered their special from Facebook-off the menu, the Mozzarella Explosion burger and the Sour Hen. Both were so, so good! Service is still exceptional! Go treat yourself!"

- Cynthia P.

"So this is a place I almost don't want to review because it was so good I want to keep it a secret. Stopped in for lunch yesterday and all I can think about is how good that sandwich was still. Honestly the best sandwich I have had ever period. Such good flavor and everything just went together. And everything on the menu looks amazing. Waitress was awesome super nice and helpful. I went in wanting a patty melt and asked he about the Sully's Trashcan and she gave me that look and told me thats the most popular one and I know why. I can't wait to be back."

- Ryan S.
Write a Review

Why Visit

Visiting Sully's GastroPub is a must for several reasons. First, the burgers are noteworthy, with unique options like the 'Smack Your Grandma' burger and the irresistible 'Sully's Trashcan' sandwich. Each dish showcases quality ingredients and bold flavors. The combination of creativity and classic comfort makes it stand out.

Additionally, the extensive beer selection pairs perfectly with any meal. You can enjoy a local craft beer or opt for a refreshing cocktail. Sully's also provides an inviting atmosphere for casual dining or a fun night out. The presence of pool tables adds another layer of enjoyment, allowing guests to mingle and unwind. Visiting during peak hours can be bustling, but those who prefer a calmer meal will appreciate off-peak times, such as Tuesday afternoons.

Service is another highlight. The staff is attentive and knowledgeable, ensuring a pleasant experience. Whether dining solo or in a group, the atmosphere feels welcoming and relaxed. If in town, don't miss the chance to experience Sully's unique culinary offerings and engaging environment, making for an unforgettable dining experience.

Most Liked Things

Many guests rave about the inviting atmosphere at Sully's. The combination of friendly staff and comfortable seating creates a welcoming environment. Patrons enjoy the variety of menu options, especially the unique burgers and creative sandwiches. Options like the 'Katsu Chicken' sandwich and 'Pastrami' sandwich receive numerous compliments for their flavors and generous portions. Customers also appreciate the extensive drink menu, especially the local beers and crafted cocktails.

Most Disliked Things

While many enjoy their meals at Sully's, some customers have noted a few drawbacks. Occasional issues with cleanliness have been mentioned, such as sticky floors from spilled drinks. Additionally, some dishes, like fries, were critiqued for being overly salty or limp rather than crispy. The mixed reviews surrounding certain items can lead to varied expectations on busy nights, as food quality may fluctuate during peak hours. Overall, while the atmosphere is largely positive, minor issues can affect the dining experience.

FAQ

What are the dining options at Sully's GastroPub?

Sully's offers dine-in, takeout, and delivery. Guests enjoy an upbeat atmosphere while dining in. With a variety of options, it's a great place for brunch, lunch, or dinner.

What are some must-try dishes at Sully's?

The Ultimate B.L.T. Sammich and Katsu Sando stand out. Also, check out the range of local specialties and enjoyable small plates. Tasty cocktails and craft beers complement the menu.

Is Sully's GastroPub kid-friendly?

Yes, Sully's offers high chairs and a kid's menu. Families can dine comfortably with options that appeal to younger guests. A fun spot for everyone.

How accessible is Sully's GastroPub?

The venue is wheelchair accessible, including entrances, seating, and restrooms. Parking also accommodates accessible vehicles, ensuring comfort for all.

What is the average price range at Sully's?

Expect to spend around $10 to $20 per meal. With a diverse menu, there's something for every budget. Be ready for a flavorful experience without breaking the bank.